Faith Beyond Nihilism: The Retrieval of Theism in Milbank and Taylor

@article{citeulike:2782015, abstract = {This article examines the thought of John Milbank and Charles Taylor, taking them as case studies which suggest, from a philosophical perspective, what a post-metaphysical conception of the religious might look like. It highlights, firstly, how their work takes on board many features of the Nietzschean critique of religion, eschewing foundationalism and absolutism, while retaining a positive notion of faith, as dogmatic theology for Millbank and as one viable form of meaning in modernity for Taylor. It identifies, secondly, the alternative grounding for such reconceptions as broadly communitarian in character, lying in the cultural and historical consitions of spiritual meanings and practices. This entails an immanent turn which removes the need for absolutist justifications and so undercuts claims for religious superiority. Milbank's postmodern Christian apologetics exemplifies such a position and yet at the same time involves exclusivist claims for the superiority of the Christian faith which, I argue, forecloses a genuine engagement with a pluralist reality. In contrast, Taylor's more tentative diagnosis of the state of Western culture and faith involves an openness to change and to the legitimacy of other accounts of moral reality, and signals how a new conception of the problem of faith and pluralism might emerge out of a refigured theism.}, author = {Klaushofer, Alexandra }, citeulike-article-id = {2782015}, doi = {10.1111/1468-2265.00098}, journal = {The Heythrop Journal}, keywords = {charles-taylor, milbank, theology}, number = {2}, pages = {135--149}, posted-at = {2008-05-10 00:48:19}, priority = {2}, title = {Faith Beyond Nihilism: The Retrieval of Theism in Milbank and Taylor}, url = {http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1468-2265.00098}, volume = {40}, year = {1999} }

TY - JOUR ID - citeulike:2782015 L3 - citeulike-article-id:2782015 TI - Faith Beyond Nihilism: The Retrieval of Theism in Milbank and Taylor JF - The Heythrop Journal VL - 40 IS - 2 SP - 135 EP - 149 N2 - This article examines the thought of John Milbank and Charles Taylor, taking them as case studies which suggest, from a philosophical perspective, what a post-metaphysical conception of the religious might look like. It highlights, firstly, how their work takes on board many features of the Nietzschean critique of religion, eschewing foundationalism and absolutism, while retaining a positive notion of faith, as dogmatic theology for Millbank and as one viable form of meaning in modernity for Taylor. It identifies, secondly, the alternative grounding for such reconceptions as broadly communitarian in character, lying in the cultural and historical consitions of spiritual meanings and practices. This entails an immanent turn which removes the need for absolutist justifications and so undercuts claims for religious superiority. Milbank's postmodern Christian apologetics exemplifies such a position and yet at the same time involves exclusivist claims for the superiority of the Christian faith which, I argue, forecloses a genuine engagement with a pluralist reality. In contrast, Taylor's more tentative diagnosis of the state of Western culture and faith involves an openness to change and to the legitimacy of other accounts of moral reality, and signals how a new conception of the problem of faith and pluralism might emerge out of a refigured theism. KW - charles-taylor KW - milbank KW - theology AU - Klaushofer, Alexandra PY - 1999/// UR - http://www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1468-2265.00098 ER -